| PLAYER | “1898” team | VRFL team | Jenkins bucket toss | Kelly shoot the gap | $10 fee savings |
| D Ginocchio | Phillies | Braves | |||
| S Fitzlaff | Orioles | Red Sox | |||
| C Smith | Phillies | Indians | 1 | ||
| R Love | Browns | Red Sox | 1 | ||
| K Blanchfield | Spiders | Cubs | $10 | ||
| X Bryson | Bridegrooms | Athletics | |||
| C Mason | Bridegrooms | Cardinals | |||
| C Williams | Phillies | Tigers | |||
| A Costales | Reds | Yankees | 1 | 1 | |
| L Coats | Reds | Browns | 1 | 1 | $10 |
| J Hobbs | Colonels | Giants | 2 | ||
| S Youngblood | Spiders | Red Sox | 1 | 2 | $10 |
| J Willliams | Orioles | Browns | 1 | ||
| H Pennington | Browns | Giants | |||
| C Wood | Orphans | Dodgers | 2 | ||
| J Young | Orphans | Pirates | 1 | ||
| R Hilton | Orphans | Giants | |||
| H Miller | Browns | Cubs | |||
| L Brawner | Colonels | Cardinals | |||
| T Kasper | Colonels | Pirates | 1 | 1 | |
| M Kasper | Bridegrooms | Yankees | 1 | 2 | $10 |
| B Richter | Browns | Yankees | |||